Accept Multiple Payments with Squarespace Commerce

Setting up different payment methods on your Squarespace store can help you capture more sales and give your customers the flexibility they want at checkout.

Accept Multiple Payments with Squarespace Commerce
Last Edited Time
Jun 25, 2025 09:35 PM
Do not index
Do not index
Suggested Tag
Accept Multiple Payments with Squarespace Commerce
squarespace
payment integration
Tags Synced
Tags Synced
AI summary
Set up various payment methods on Squarespace to boost sales, including built-in options, Stripe, PayPal, and Square for in-person sales. Test each method and monitor customer preferences for optimal checkout experience.
Last edited by
Platform
Category
Topic

Accept Multiple Payments with Squarespace Commerce

Setting up different payment methods on your Squarespace store can help you capture more sales and give your customers the flexibility they want at checkout.

TL;DR: Key Points

  • Accept major credit cards and alternative payment options via Squarespace Payments
  • Connect with Stripe and PayPal for expanded payment capabilities
  • Use Square for in-person payments and sync them with your online sales
  • Check country availability for certain payment features on Squarespace's website

Your Payment Method Options

Squarespace gives you several ways to accept payments. You can use their built-in payment system, connect third-party processors, or combine multiple options. Here's what works best for different situations.

Squarespace Payments: The Built-in Option

Squarespace Payments handles most payment types you'll need:
  • Credit cards (Visa, Mastercard, American Express)
  • Apple Pay for mobile shoppers
  • Buy-now-pay-later options like Afterpay/Clearpay and Klarna
  • ACH bank transfers (US merchants only)
The main advantage is everything stays within Squarespace. You get unified reporting and don't need to juggle multiple dashboards. The downside is availability - it's not rolled out everywhere yet.

Third-Party Payment Processors

Stripe Integration

Stripe connects easily with Squarespace and accepts:
  • All major credit and debit cards
  • Discover cards (US only)
  • Diner's Club and JCB cards
  • Apple Pay and PayPal
Stripe works in more countries than Squarespace Payments and often has more advanced features for subscription billing or complex checkout flows.

PayPal Business

A PayPal Business account lets customers pay with PayPal or Venmo. Many people trust PayPal for online purchases, especially for higher-value items or unfamiliar brands.

Square for In-Person Sales

If you sell at markets, pop-ups, or have a physical location, Square syncs your in-person and online inventory. Customers can buy online and collect in-store, or you can process card and cash payments that automatically update your Squarespace stock levels.
Pixelhaze Tip: Test every payment method with small transactions before launching. Nothing kills sales faster than a broken checkout process.

Common Questions

Can I use multiple payment processors at once? Yes, but be careful not to overcomplicate checkout. Too many options can confuse customers. Pick 2-3 methods that cover your main customer preferences.
Which payment method has the lowest fees? Fees vary by region and transaction volume. Compare the total cost including monthly fees, transaction percentages, and any setup costs. For most small stores, the differences are minimal.
Do I need PayPal if I already have Stripe? It depends on your customers. Some people prefer PayPal for security or because they don't want to enter card details. Check your analytics to see if customers abandon checkout - they might be looking for PayPal.
Can customers save payment details for repeat purchases? Yes, but this depends on which payment processor you use. Squarespace Payments and Stripe both support saved payment methods for return customers.

Quick Setup Guide

  1. Start with one payment method - Get this working perfectly before adding others
  1. Test the entire checkout flow - Buy something from your own store to check the customer experience
  1. Set up payment confirmations - Make sure customers get clear receipts and you get proper notifications
  1. Check mobile checkout - Most customers shop on phones, so test this carefully
  1. Add other payment methods gradually - Monitor which ones customers actually use

Jargon Buster

Payment Gateway: The service that processes card payments and transfers money to your account. Think of it as the bridge between your store and the banking system.
ACH Transfers: Direct bank-to-bank transfers that bypass card networks. Usually cheaper for large transactions but take longer to process.
Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL): Services like Klarna and Afterpay that let customers split purchases into instalments. Popular with younger customers.
PCI Compliance: Security standards for handling card data. Most payment processors handle this for you, but worth understanding if customers ask about security.
The key is starting simple and adding payment methods based on what your customers actually want. Check your region's available options on Squarespace's website, as features vary by country.

Join our Free Membership and access our DIY Community.

Need help with your website

Become a member