Generative Fill Isn’t Magic: How to Actually Use It Well

Why This Matters

You’ve seen the videos on social media: a few brush strokes, a single line prompt, and suddenly a stubborn thumb disappears, a sky blooms into fire, or boring backgrounds morph into award-winning vistas. Photoshop’s Generative Fill in the 2025 update looks remarkable, sometimes even effortless. If you're here, chances are you’ve tried it yourself, only to discover the gap between the hype and reality. Instead of instant masterpieces, you get smeared edges, lighting that looks like it was invented by a committee, or objects that dissolve into visual porridge if you so much as squint at them wrong.

Generative Fill can be an effective tool, but it isn’t the magical solution many expect. If you use it carelessly, you will spend hours patching up mistakes and lose productive time. For agencies and freelancers, those hours add up to lost revenue (and maybe a frazzled client or two). For in-house creators, missed deadlines and patchy branding hurt your reputation. To achieve fast, believable results, you need to guide the AI properly and know exactly where to make adjustments. Otherwise, you end up trading labour for educated guesswork with a layer of digital frosting on top.

Joun Pixelhaze for free and gain access to courses, plugins and discounts.

Common Pitfalls

Almost everyone who tries Generative Fill trips over the same set of wires:

• Vague Prompts: “Add a cat” gives wildly variable results, most of which look like taxidermy gone wrong. The AI isn’t psychic. If you’re specific, you'll get specific.
• Messy Selections: The lazy lasso: you select a rough blob, hit ‘generative fill’, and wonder why your new background looks like it’s breaking out of its own frame.
• Ignoring Lighting Direction: The fastest way to spot a fake? Shadows going east when the sun’s coming from the west.
• Skipping Masks: Letting Generative Fill guess your intent across an unmasked photo is like expecting a toddler to colour within the lines. Sometimes you get funny results, but it rarely looks professional.
• Believing Social Media Myths: Spoiler: It won’t generate perfect feet, realistic reflections, or match your product shots to the lighting in every stock photo. TikTok didn’t tell you that.

Believing Generative Fill works by default leads straight to mediocrity. Misunderstanding its limits results in wasted afternoons.

Step-by-Step Fix

1. Start With a Clean, Clear Selection

Accuracy starts here. If your selection is sloppy, the AI fills are too. Use Photoshop’s ‘Select Subject’ for major elements, or the Lasso tool for custom areas. Slow down and make clean selections.

Practical Example: Expanding a product photo? Select only the blank edges where you want to add content. Avoid crossing into the product’s edges. If you're removing a person, include a tight, natural margin around them, not jagged lines or random blobs.

2. Tell the AI Exactly What You Want (Really, Say It)

"Generate a nicer sky" might just get you something blue, sometimes with a surprise mountain. Instead, try: "Clear blue sky, early evening, gentle golden light, scattered clouds."

Practical Example: Need to fill in a gap at the edge of a room interior? Don’t just say, “fill wall.” Instead: “Continue white painted wall, soft shadow, wooden skirting, no windows, consistent with existing texture.”

Prompt breakdown:

• State the object or area
• Specify colours and textures
• Clarify lighting (soft, hard, direction?)
• Note anything to exclude (“no people”, “no watermark”)

3. Check and Match the Lighting Direction

Lighting mismatches are where most edits go wrong. Photoshop’s Firefly model will try to interpret your lighting, but it’s really just guessing. Match the lighting by prompting: “right side soft shadow”, “top left light source”, or “sunset glow from behind.”

Practical Example: For product photography, if the left side is brightly lit, mention it. If you’re generating a jacket sleeve, specify: “left-lit sleeve, strong back shadow.”

Before moving on, zoom in and check the way highlights and shadows fall on your new content. Subtle mismatches are a dead giveaway.

4. Use Masks for Local Control and Clean Up the Edges

Don’t leave boundaries entirely to the AI. Generate your fill on a new layer or as a masked selection (Photoshop does this by default, but double-check).

Practical Example: If you’re expanding a landscape photo, use a soft brush on the mask to manually blend the horizon where the AI stitches new pixels. If filling a missing corner of a product, gently erase with a low-opacity brush along the edge for clarity.

5. Refine, Repeat, and Don’t Hesitate to Hit 'Refresh'

AI fills aren’t consistent. If your first generation looks terrible, regenerate. Each attempt can be wildly different; don’t settle, and don’t use the first result out of impatience.

Practical Example: Need surreal edits? First, prompt for the base. Regenerate until you spot something you love. If it’s nearly perfect but missing detail, mask that chunk and fill just that area again.

For subtle expansions (like thumbnail borders), try three or four generations before you pick your winner. Sometimes you just need a new random output to find the standout version.

6. Save Variations, Then Polish Manually

Generative Fill can generate interesting options, but you still need manual input for the finishing touch. Save your favourite versions, then combine details manually: a sky from take three, ground from take two, some shadow magic from take six.

Practical Example: On a product shot, keep the generated reflection from one fill, but swap in the edge detail from another. Use layer masks to blend both.

What Most People Miss

Generative Fill cannot fix a poor composition; it only expands what’s already there. A layout that’s off-centre doesn’t become more balanced just by adding extra sky. The tool invents plausible pixels based on your prompt, rather than producing exactly what makes a portfolio piece.

You make real progress when you treat the AI as a creative shortcut instead of a replacement for editing skills. This means defining your goal, guiding the outcome with precise selections, and being ready to improve the output. The most skilled retouchers refine Firefly results—cleaning up rough edges, adjusting shadows, and sometimes blending multiple AI outputs for one strong composite.

Pixelhaze veterans have a proven approach: the AI does the rough work, but your expertise chooses what stays. Mastering this tool comes from seeking control, not believing in shortcuts.

The Bigger Picture

With purposeful use, Generative Fill can boost your workflow speed by 10–50% on various projects. For repetitive product edits, it provides significant time savings. For agencies balancing client turnaround and quality, it cuts time spent on routine tasks, freeing you to polish work or explore new ideas. Over a year, this baseline efficiency adds up. What begins with a small product expansion translates to hundreds of hours saved, giving you space for additional projects or extra refinement that sets you apart.

Advanced knowledge of Generative Fill makes a team both faster and more adaptable. While the average user posts before-and-after shots on LinkedIn, you’ll be serving clients with genuinely impressive images, not just algorithm-chasing content. As competitors experiment with Canva’s Magic Edit or Affinity’s Inpainting, you will understand each tool's strengths and limitations, using the right one for every job.

On to the next comparison…

Firefly Fill vs Canva Magic Edit vs Affinity Inpainting: Which AI Wins?

Let’s put the three most hyped tools side by side.

Photoshop's Generative Fill (Firefly)

Strengths:

• Deep integration with pro workflows (layers, masks, full adjustment toolset)
• Detailed prompt response when used well
• Quality edges and plausible blends (if patched/tweaked with care)
• Handles product shots, surreal edits, and intricate expansions better than rivals

Weaknesses:

• Struggles with hands, feet, and fine details (just like most AI)
• Needs human input to fix lighting, shadow, and edge mismatches
• Doesn’t deliver instant one-click output and requires your input

Best for: Creative control, professional retouching, extensible edits

Canva Magic Edit

Strengths:

• Extremely simple: draw a blob, type a quick prompt
• Great for bulk, low-stakes content (social posts, internal docs)
• Decent job on backgrounds and basic object addition

Weaknesses:

• Limited to simple prompts, often generic results
• Struggles with matching lighting and complex textures
• Lacks fine adjustment (no layer/mask system like Photoshop)

Best for: Rapid content, social media graphics, non-specialist users

Affinity Photo Inpainting

Strengths:

• Quick, easy fill/removal for obvious background issues
• Good for dust, scratch, and simple object removal
• Fast performance, no cloud lag

Weaknesses:

• No prompt system; fills are blind guesses based on nearby pixels
• Strictly for patching; not for creating new elements
• Not suited for adding new content or detailed expansions

Best for: Clean-up, restoration work, fixing small mistakes

Pixelhaze Verdict:
If you want real control and polished outcomes, Generative Fill is the strongest option as long as you’re ready to get hands-on. Canva’s Magic Edit is a good pick when you want speed without effort. For quick clean-up, Affinity is ahead. Sometimes, it’s best to use all three on a project. Each tool has its strengths, but none should be treated as a magic wand.

Mythbusting: What Generative Fill Really Does

Let’s clear the fog. These are the three biggest myths cropping up everywhere:

Myth 1: “It fixes anything with one click”
Reality: The AI’s only as good as your prompt and your selection. Shoddy input equals shoddy output. Expect to refine things, sometimes more than once.

Myth 2: “AI knows what your image needs”
Reality: Generative Fill has no idea what you want unless you spell it out. If you don’t state, “no text,” you might get random copyright gibberish floating in the sky. If you want realism, you have to nudge it there.

Myth 3: “Lighting, shadows and detail get matched perfectly”
Reality: 90% good most times, 10% uncanny valley. Always patch shadows, check for mismatched light, and fix weird artefacts manually. No AI catches everything.

Bonus: “It’s basically the same as Canva/Affinity”
Reality: Canva’s Magic Edit stays basic and shallow. Affinity Inpainting only patches. Photoshop’s Firefly gives you meaningful control when you take time with it.

FAQs and Jargon Buster

What makes a ‘good’ Generative Fill prompt?
Be as precise as possible: describe colours, mood, placement, and any details not visible in your selection.

How do I fix bad edges or jarring light after using Generative Fill?
Use masks and adjustment layers to blend the seam. Tweak shadows and highlights so the new content matches the real image.

Why did Generative Fill add weird objects or text?
Vague prompts or bad selections confuse the AI. Re-select and rewrite your prompt with specifics. Always state what you don’t want as well as what you do.

Can Generative Fill recreate sharp details for upscaling?
No, this is not an upscaler. If you try to make your dog thumbnail into an A1 poster, expect fuzzy artefacts and ‘oil painting’ faces. For poster-ready quality, always start big or use a dedicated upscaling tool.

Pixelhaze Tip Box (Print and Stick to Your Monitor)

- Always feather your selections
- Be absurdly clear and detailed in your prompts
- Check and match lighting direction every time
- Mask, zoom in, and blend edges manually
- Save every variation—Frankenstein when needed
- Don’t believe the hype, trust your eye

Wrap-Up

Photoshop’s Generative Fill is clever, fast, and its results reflect the skill of the person using it. With the right approach, it will reduce your editing time, help spark new ideas, and introduce new solutions to familiar challenges. Without careful use, it leads to wasted hours and extra cleanup.

Focus on crisp selections, detailed prompts, and a careful review of lighting and texture. No tool delivers miracles, but a refined process consistently delivers stronger results.

Want more helpful systems like this? Join Pixelhaze Academy for free at https://www.pixelhaze.academy/membership. Grab our free AI Fill cheatsheet or explore our full Photoshop & AI crash course (links on the site).

Go fill some gaps. Make sure you stay in control of the outcome.