Common Claude Prompting Challenges

Learning Objectives

1. Identify why Claude may expand or hedge in response to given instructions
2. Learn methods to formulate prompts that yield clear, structured, and focused responses
3. Understand how to effectively control Claude's output to match the desired scope and detail

Introduction

When working with Claude, you'll likely encounter responses that feel too broad, overly cautious, or miss the mark entirely. These aren't random quirks. Claude has specific patterns in how it interprets and responds to prompts, and once you understand these patterns, you can work with them rather than against them.

This chapter covers the most common challenges you'll face when prompting Claude and gives you practical techniques to get the responses you actually want.

Lessons

Lesson 1: Why Claude Expands and Hedges

Claude often gives longer, more cautious responses than you need. This happens for two main reasons: it's designed to be helpful by covering multiple angles, and it tries to account for ambiguity in your prompt.

Expansion occurs when Claude elaborates beyond what you asked for. If you ask "How do I write better emails?", Claude might cover tone, structure, subject lines, timing, and follow-ups when you only wanted help with tone.

Hedging happens when Claude gives non-committal answers. Instead of saying "Do X", it might say "You could consider doing X, though Y might also work depending on your situation."

Step 1: Look for these patterns in Claude's responses:

• Responses that start broad then narrow down
• Multiple caveats or "it depends" statements
• Lists that seem longer than necessary
• Phrases like "you might want to consider" or "it could be helpful to"

Step 2: Notice which prompts trigger these responses:

• Vague or open-ended questions
• Prompts without clear context
• Requests that could apply to multiple situations

Lesson 2: Getting More Direct Responses

You can guide Claude toward more focused responses by changing how you structure your prompts.

Step 1: Be specific about what you want
Instead of "Help me with my presentation", try "Give me three ways to make my slide transitions smoother in PowerPoint."

Step 2: Set boundaries in your prompt
Add phrases like:

• "Give me just the main point"
• "Keep it under 100 words"
• "Focus only on the technical steps"

Step 3: Ask for a specific format
Say "Give me a numbered list" or "Write this as bullet points" rather than leaving the format open.

Lesson 3: Controlling Response Scope

The trick to getting useful responses is controlling how much ground Claude tries to cover.

Step 1: Narrow your topic
Break broad topics into specific questions. Instead of asking about "social media strategy", ask about "posting frequency for LinkedIn company updates."

Step 2: Provide context upfront
Tell Claude your situation: "I'm a freelance designer with 50 Instagram followers" rather than just "How do I grow on Instagram?"

Step 3: Use examples to show what you want
Say "Like this example…" and show Claude the style or format you're after.

Step 4: Ask follow-up questions
If the first response is too broad, ask "Which of these is most important?" or "Start with just the first point."

Practice

Try these three prompts with Claude and notice the difference in responses:

1. Broad prompt: "How do I improve my writing?"
2. Specific prompt: "Give me three techniques to make my email subject lines more compelling."
3. Contextual prompt: "I'm writing weekly newsletters for small business owners. Give me three techniques to make my email subject lines more compelling, with examples."

Compare how focused and actionable each response is. The more specific and contextual your prompt, the more useful Claude's response will be.

FAQs

Why does Claude sometimes give me vague responses?
Usually because your prompt is open to multiple interpretations. Claude hedges when it's unsure what you specifically need.

How do I get Claude to be more direct?
Ask for specific formats, set word limits, or explicitly request "Give me a direct answer" in your prompt.

What's the best way to avoid overly long responses?
Set boundaries upfront. Use phrases like "in one sentence" or "just the key steps" to signal the scope you want.

Jargon Buster

Expansion: When Claude provides more comprehensive coverage of a topic than requested, often exploring related areas or providing extensive background.

Hedging: Claude's tendency to give qualified, cautious responses rather than direct statements, typically using phrases like "might," "could," or "depending on the situation."

Prompt context: The background information and specific details you provide to help Claude understand your situation and needs.

Wrap-up

Claude works best when you give it clear direction. Rather than fighting against its natural tendencies to be comprehensive and cautious, use specific prompts that channel these tendencies toward what you actually need.

Start with narrow, contextual prompts and use follow-up questions to refine the responses. The more you practice this approach, the faster you'll get useful answers from Claude.

Next, you'll learn how to structure complex prompts that get Claude to handle multi-step tasks effectively.

Join Pixelhaze Academy